
Marriott Sanibel Harbour Resort & Spa
Best for families, groups and guests who want many on-site facilities (pools, multiple restaurants, large spa and event space).
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Marriott Sanibel Harbour Resort & Spa is a large waterfront Fort Myers resort with multiple pools, restaurants, a 40,000 sq ft spa and family-friendly programming. Island Inn is a small, historic beachfront inn on Sanibel Island that suits travelers after a quieter, classic island stay.
Updated

Best for families, groups and guests who want many on-site facilities (pools, multiple restaurants, large spa and event space).

Best for travelers who want a low-key, beach-facing inn on Sanibel with easy access to island beaches and bike trails.
When Marriott Sanibel Harbour Resort & Spa wins: Choose Marriott if you want a full-service resort setup — multiple dining venues, a large on-site spa and a variety of pools and activities for kids and adults.
When Island Inn wins: Choose Island Inn if your priority is a small, historic beachfront property on Sanibel Island where you can walk to the sand, rent a bike on site and enjoy a quieter island pace.
Bottom line: Marriott is a bigger Fort Myers resort for amenity-rich stays and events; Island Inn is a compact Sanibel beachfront inn for travelers focused on simple beach access and an island atmosphere.
| Category | Marriott Sanibel Harbour Resort & Spa | Island Inn |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Resort campus with active programming, multiple venues and meeting space | Historic, low-rise beachfront inn with a quiet island feel |
| Location | Fort Myers peninsula (Punta Rassa) facing Sanibel/Captiva, near the Sanibel Causeway | Sanibel Island (West End) on a private beach at 3111 W Gulf Dr |
| Size | Large — 347 rooms across multiple buildings | Small — 20 individually decorated guestrooms |
| Who it's for / ages | All ages — family-friendly activities and kid programming | All ages — low-key beach stay; not adults-only |
| Pools | Multiple outdoor pools plus a heated indoor pool (one pool listed as adults-only) | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Six+ on-site options including Tarpon House, Courtside Steakhouse, Charley's Cabana Bar and a dinner-cruise yacht | Not a full restaurant roster; property highlights private kitchens/kitchenettes in rooms and limited front-desk hours for services |
| Spa & wellness | The Spa at Sanibel Harbour — 40,000 sq ft, 28 treatment rooms, steam/sauna/whirlpool | Health/beauty spa listed as nearby (no large on-site spa) |
| Known for | Full-service resort amenities, waterfront location and event/wedding facilities | Historic beachfront inn, direct beach access and on-site bicycle rentals |
| Rooms (examples) | Varied room types incl. Studio, 1‑bedroom suites and balcony tower rooms with water or resort views | Gulfview Studio; Luxury Suite, Sea View; Gulfview Luxury Suite — rooms include kitchens |
| Parking & access | Self parking and valet available (fees listed on property site); EV charging | Free self parking and uncovered/covered parking available |
Marriott Sanibel Harbour Resort & Spa sits on an 85-acre peninsula at Punta Rassa, facing Sanibel and Captiva, just before the Sanibel Causeway.
Choose Marriott if you want a waterfront Fort Myers base with easy car access to Sanibel and regional attractions.
Island Inn is a small historic inn on Sanibel’s West End with direct access to a private stretch of beach.
Choose Island Inn if you want to stay directly on Sanibel and spend more time on the island rather than in Fort Myers.
Marriott offers a wide range of room types across towers and buildings, from balcony rooms to suites and studio options.
Marriott works for travelers who want choices in room size, views and family-friendly bedding arrangements.
Island Inn has 20 individually decorated guestrooms, many with kitchen facilities suited to longer island stays.
Island Inn is a good pick if you prefer simple rooms with kitchens and a small-property feel.
Marriott has multiple full-service dining venues and a dinner-cruise yacht, covering everything from casual poolside meals to a steakhouse.
Marriott suits guests who value diverse on-site dining and evening options without leaving the resort.
Island Inn’s rooms have kitchen facilities and the property focuses on beach and local dining rather than many on-site restaurants.
Island Inn is best for travelers who plan to eat on the island or use in-room kitchens rather than rely on hotel restaurants.
Marriott guests have multiple pool options plus nearby beach access on Sanibel Harbour Beach.
Marriott is ideal if you want several pool environments and easy beach access without leaving the property.
Island Inn emphasizes direct access to a private beach and low-key seaside recreation.
Island Inn works well for travelers whose main priority is immediate beach access and seaside relaxation.
Marriott provides a full-service spa and multiple evening dining and bar options across the property.
Marriott is the choice for guests wanting an on-site spa, structured fitness options and nighttime dining/drinks.
Island Inn focuses on outdoor recreation and a quiet island rhythm rather than a large spa or active nightlife.
Island Inn fits travelers who prefer outdoor activity and low-key evenings on Sanibel rather than resort nightlife.

Marriott — multiple pools, kids' activities and family-friendly dining make it easier to keep children entertained on site.

Marriott — The Spa at Sanibel Harbour is a large, full-service facility with many treatment rooms and amenities.

Island Inn — small scale, historic property with direct access to a private stretch of Sanibel beach and bike rentals.

Island Inn — guestrooms include kitchens (full-sized refrigerators and ovens), which suit guests who prefer to self-cater.
Marriott Sanibel Harbour Resort & Spa — it offers kids' programming, multiple pools and family-focused dining options.
Island Inn — it's a Sanibel beachfront property with direct beach access and easy island bike/shore access.
Island Inn rooms list full kitchens (refrigerator/freezer and oven). Marriott rooms typically do not include full kitchens; check specific room descriptions before booking.
Marriott Sanibel Harbour Resort & Spa has The Spa at Sanibel Harbour, a large full-service spa. Island Inn lists a nearby health/beauty spa rather than a large on-site facility.
Explore how Marriott Sanibel Harbour Resort & Spa stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·