
Marriott Sanibel Harbour Resort & Spa
Best for families and guests who want on-site spa, multiple pools, restaurants, event space, and a broad program of activities.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Marriott Sanibel Harbour Resort & Spa is a large, full-service waterfront resort and spa on a private peninsula near Sanibel Causeway; read this if you want a multi-venue resort with a big spa, meeting space, and family amenities. Matanzas Inn Bayside Resort and Marina is a smaller bayside Fort Myers Beach inn and marina — read this if you want a compact, boating‑oriented stay steps from Fort Myers Beach attractions.
Updated

Best for families and guests who want on-site spa, multiple pools, restaurants, event space, and a broad program of activities.

Best for travelers who prefer a compact, waterfront Fort Myers Beach stay with easy access to boat tours, the Key West Express, and a relaxed bayside setting.
When Marriott Sanibel Harbour Resort & Spa wins: Choose the Marriott for a resort-scale stay — dozens of meeting rooms and ballrooms, six on-site dining venues including a steakhouse and a dinner-cruise yacht, a 40,000‑sq ft spa with many treatments, multiple pools (including indoor options), and family programming.
When Matanzas Inn Bayside Resort and Marina wins: Choose Matanzas Inn for a smaller, highly rated bayside inn that puts you close to Fort Myers Beach attractions and boat activity; it’s simpler, walkable to Times Square and Estero Boulevard, and has an on-site restaurant and marina-friendly services.
Bottom line: Pick Marriott for resort amenities, spa time, and event capacity; pick Matanzas Inn for a compact, waterfront Fort Myers Beach base and strong guest ratings when you want a lower‑scale, marina‑area experience.
| Category | Marriott Sanibel Harbour Resort & Spa | Matanzas Inn Bayside Resort and Marina |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Large, full-service resort and spa with many guest facilities and event spaces | Small, relaxed bayside inn and marina with a compact, walkable property |
| Location | On an 85-acre peninsula beside Sanibel Harbour Beach and San Carlos Bay | Bayside Fort Myers Beach address near Times Square and Estero Boulevard |
| Size (rooms) | About 347 rooms across multiple towers | 27 rooms (small inn) |
| Ages / audience | All-ages resort; kids’ activities and family pools available | All-ages property (not adults-only) with family rooms and cottages |
| Pools | Multiple outdoor pools plus a heated indoor pool; some pools are named and hours posted | One outdoor pool and one hot tub |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple venues (Tarpon House, Courtside Steakhouse, Charley’s Cabana Bar, The Cove, Palm Court Bakery, plus dinner-cruise yacht) | One on-site restaurant (Petey's Upper Deck) and a bar/lounge |
| Spa & wellness | The Spa at Sanibel Harbour — 40,000 sq ft, 28 treatment rooms, steam/sauna/whirlpool, signature treatments | Not published |
| Marina / boating | On-site boat tours and a private 100-foot yacht (Sanibel Harbour Princess) for dinner cruises | Marina-oriented inn with on-site fishing, nearby boat tours and easy access to Key West Express |
| Parking & transport | Self-parking and valet (fees apply), EV charging station; no hotel shuttle (third-party options available) | Free self parking on site; front desk staffed limited hours |
| Guest rating / stars | Upscale full-service resort (official Marriott listing; 4–5 star positioning on many sites) | 3-star, guest rating 9.4 (supplier listing) |
Marriott Sanibel Harbour sits on a private peninsula at Punta Rassa with short walks to Sanibel Harbour Beach and views toward Sanibel and Captiva.
A good choice if you want a resort on a private peninsula with easy boat‑access to nearby islands.
Matanzas Inn sits on Crescent Street in Fort Myers Beach with direct bayside/marina orientation and walkable access to local beach attractions.
Choose Matanzas Inn if you want immediate Fort Myers Beach access and easy marina/boat activity.
Marriott offers about 14 room types across multiple towers, including waterfront suites and balcony rooms.
More room types and larger suites at Marriott suit guests who want upgrade options and water-view balconies.
Matanzas Inn has 27 air-conditioned rooms in a small inn footprint with options like Waterside Queen and Bayside 2 Bedroom w/ Balcony.
Matanzas Inn works if you want a compact, no‑frills bayside room with basic kitchenette-type amenities and balcony options.
Marriott provides a range of on-site restaurants and bars for casual and upscale meals.
Expect more variety and both casual and upscale dining at Marriott without leaving the property.
Matanzas Inn operates a single on-site restaurant and bar/lounge for guest dining.
Matanzas Inn is convenient for grab-and-go and local seafood dining but offers less on-property variety.
Marriott features multiple outdoor pools and a heated indoor pool plus poolside dining and cabanas.
If you want pool variety plus quick beach access, the resort’s multiple pool options are its strength.
Matanzas Inn has a single outdoor pool and one hot tub for guests.
Matanzas Inn suits guests who prioritize beach and marina access over multiple resort pools.
Marriott’s wellness offering centers on a large spa, round-the-clock fitness, and scheduled activities.
Marriott is the pick for guests who want a full-service spa and a range of scheduled wellness activities on property.
Matanzas Inn leans into low-key waterfront life, easy access to local bars/restaurants and boat tours rather than resort spa programming.
Pick Matanzas Inn if you want a quieter, waterfront-focused stay and plan to use local businesses for wellness or nightlife.

Marriott — The Spa at Sanibel Harbour is a full 40,000‑sq ft facility with many treatment rooms and signature services.

Matanzas Inn — Small property with marina orientation, easy walkability to Fort Myers Beach attractions.

Marriott — Multiple on-site venues including a steakhouse, poolside restaurant, coffee shop and a dinner-cruise yacht.

Matanzas Inn — 3-star inn with a strong guest rating (9.4) and straightforward bayside amenities.
Marriott — it offers kids’ activities, kid-friendly pools and family-oriented dining; Matanzas Inn is family-friendly but much smaller and more limited in on-site kid programming.
Marriott — it has The Spa at Sanibel Harbour with extensive treatment rooms and signature services; Matanzas Inn does not publish a comparable on-site spa.
Yes — Matanzas Inn positions itself as a bayside inn and marina property with fishing on site and easy access to local boat tours and the Key West Express area.
No — neither property is an all-inclusive property; meals and drinks are generally charged separately.
Explore how Marriott Sanibel Harbour Resort & Spa stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·